Cardinal Vincent Nichols celebrating a traditional mass in 2014. Photo: InfoVaticana

After 25 years, Catholic Archbishop of Westminster decides there will be no Old Rite liturgy during Holy Week

The denial of permissions for the Triduum follows a series of decisions curtailing traditional liturgical practices in Westminster. In 2021, the long-standing tradition of ordinations in the old rite was discontinued, followed by the cessation of the Latin Mass Society’s annual requiem Mass in Westminster Cathedral in November 2023. Additionally, a 50-year-old tradition of holding two annual old rite Masses in the cathedral came to an end.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Share this Entry

(ZENIT News / London, 02.29.2024).- This year, the Diocese of Westminster will not host the liturgical celebrations of the Easter Triduum in the ancient Traditional Latin rite, breaking from a tradition that has been upheld since the 1990s. The decision, made by Cardinal Vincent Nichols, the archbishop of the diocese, and the leading figure for Catholics in England and Wales, marks a significant shift in the liturgical landscape of the region.

In correspondence with Fr. Michael Cullinan, who sought to host this year’s Triduum at St. Mary Moorfields, the only Catholic church in The Square Mile of the City of London, Cardinal Nichols expressed awareness that the decision would disappoint some. He cited the need to consider the broader context, alluding to parameters set forth by the Holy See.

This decision aligns with Pope Francis’ 2021 motu proprio Traditiones Custodes and subsequent directives from Cardinal Arthur Roche, head of the Dicastery for Divine Worship, who has been vocal in his opposition to the traditional liturgy. Cardinal Nichols emphasized his cooperation with the Holy See in this matter, underscoring his commitment to the wider provision of the traditional liturgy in the archdiocese.

The denial of permissions for the Triduum follows a series of decisions curtailing traditional liturgical practices in Westminster. In 2021, the long-standing tradition of ordinations in the old rite was discontinued, followed by the cessation of the Latin Mass Society’s annual requiem Mass in Westminster Cathedral in November 2023. Additionally, a 50-year-old tradition of holding two annual old rite Masses in the cathedral came to an end.

The relationship between the Archdiocese of Westminster and the old rite dates back to the liturgical reforms of 1970. Cardinal John Heenan, initially critical of the new mass, secured concessions from Pope Paul VI, famously known as the “Agatha Christie Indult,” granting permissions for old rite liturgies at the discretion of the archdiocese.

However, Cardinal Nichols’ recent decision to reverse the desires of prominent signatories and many Catholics reflects mounting pressure from the Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Holy See, particularly as Pope Francis’ health declines.

This decision marks a significant development in the liturgical landscape of Westminster, raising questions about the future of traditional liturgical practices in the region and the broader implications for Catholic worship in England and Wales.

Thank you for reading our content. If you would like to receive ZENIT’s daily e-mail news, you can subscribe for free through this link.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Share this Entry

Elizabeth Owens

Support ZENIT

If you liked this article, support ZENIT now with a donation