(ZENIT News / Beirut, 10.20.2024).- The serene town of Aitou in northern Lebanon, home to a largely Christian Maronite community, was left in shock and mourning after an Israeli airstrike on October 14 killed 22 civilians, including two children. Among the wreckage, a statue of Saint Charbel, the town’s revered Catholic patron, stood covered in dust, a solemn reminder of the devastation that had swept through the residential area.
The United Nations has voiced its concerns, with the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights calling for an independent investigation into the attack. The Commissioner highlighted «serious concerns regarding the laws of war and the principles of distinction and proportionality.» The bombing targeted a house that, according to local authorities, had been rented to displaced families—one of whom was reportedly linked to Hezbollah, adding a complex layer to the tragedy.
Journalist Oliver Marsden, reporting from the scene for The Times, described the aftermath in harrowing detail. Amid the debris, rescue workers found the lifeless body of a one-year-old child strapped into the backseat of a truck, surrounded by scattered children’s clothing, schoolbooks, and the charred remains of a teddy bear. «It was a vision of unimaginable loss,» Marsden wrote, as the town came to grips with the horrifying reality of civilian casualties.
A Conflict’s Complex Web of Retaliation
The Israeli military has defended its actions, stating that the airstrike was aimed at a Hezbollah facility. Tensions between Hezbollah and Israel have escalated dramatically, particularly following a drone attack by Hezbollah on October 13 that resulted in the deaths of four Israeli soldiers and injuries to dozens more. The group’s continued rocket fire into northern Israel has displaced tens of thousands of Israeli civilians, further intensifying the conflict.
For the residents of Aitou and other affected communities, however, the impact on civilian lives has been profound. Local leaders have expressed outrage at the targeting of civilian homes. Monsignor Estephan Frangieh, director of the Saydet Zgharta University Medical Center, condemned the strike, accusing Israel of sending a chilling message. «This is Israel’s way of saying, ‘Don’t shelter Shiite Muslims.’ There are rules in war, but what happened here is monstrous,» Frangieh told *The Times*.
The Israeli Defense Forces, while acknowledging civilian casualties, have pledged to investigate the incident, but this has done little to quell the anger and grief felt by the survivors. The attack in Aitou is just one episode in a broader conflict that has seen more than 2,200 deaths and left over 10,000 injured in Lebanon since October 2023, according to the UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR). Meanwhile, Israel has issued evacuation orders affecting over a quarter of Lebanon’s population, pushing 1.2 million people into displacement.
Schools Caught in the Crossfire, Communities Seek Hope
Lebanese schools, many of which have become temporary shelters for displaced families, are also being impacted by the ongoing violence. Despite the chaos, Father Mouin Saba, head of the Apostles School in Jounieh, noted that nearly 75% of Catholic schools in the country remain operational. «Through education, we can spread hope and life,» Father Saba told Catholic News Agency (ACI), emphasizing the importance of keeping schools open as beacons of stability in such uncertain times.
Teachers and community leaders share this commitment to preserving a sense of normalcy for the next generation. Noelle El Hajj, a high school teacher who lived through the Lebanese civil war as a child, spoke poignantly about the long-term effects of interrupted education. «So much potential and so many dreams were wasted then. I don’t want the same fate for this generation,» she said in an interview, reflecting on the vital role education plays in rebuilding a fractured society.
However, the conflict has made even places of refuge dangerous. On October 8, a missile strike hit a church in Derdghaya in southern Lebanon, killing at least eight people who had sought shelter there. The attack was just one of many instances where civilian spaces have been caught in the crossfire, raising further questions about the proportionality of military actions.
Gaza: A Parallel Crisis in the Shadows of War
Meanwhile, in Gaza, the conflict has also reached devastating heights. On the same day as the Aitou airstrike, an Israeli bombardment of Al Aqsa Hospital’s courtyard left five dead and dozens injured. The courtyard had been a makeshift camp for many of Gaza’s displaced residents. Survivors spoke of an apocalyptic scene, where flames from cooking gas explosions engulfed tents. «The most heart-wrenching moment is watching your neighbors burn alive and being powerless to save them,» Abed Musleh told *The New York Times*.
Israel’s military defended the attack, claiming it had targeted a command center for Hamas, the militant group governing Gaza. Yet the collateral damage has once again placed the ethics of such military strikes under intense scrutiny.
The Toll of War and the Path Forward
With no end to the violence in sight, the toll on both Lebanon and Gaza continues to mount. The displaced number in the millions, and the trauma of civilian casualties is echoed across communities. Yet, amid the grief and chaos, there are calls for justice, peace, and—most crucially—an independent assessment of the events that have left so many dead.
The tragic stories emerging from Aitou and Gaza serve as stark reminders of the human cost of war. In the words of Monsignor Frangieh, «War has rules, but we’ve crossed a line where the innocent are no longer just collateral—they’ve become targets.» His plea, and those of so many others affected by this conflict, is for the international community to take action before more lives are lost.
Thank you for reading our content. If you would like to receive ZENIT’s daily e-mail news, you can subscribe for free through this link.
