(ZENIT News / Portland, 09.04.2024).- Alliance Defending Freedom attorneys representing an Oregon youth ministry filed an opening brief Monday 26 August with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit after a lower court dismissed the case. Youth 71Five Ministries, which serves at-risk youth, is challenging state officials who stripped the ministry of previously approved funds simply because it asks employees and volunteers to sign a statement of faith. Earlier this month, the 9th Circuit allowed 71Five Ministries to receive needed funds from the state as the appeal proceeds.
From 2017 to 2023, 71Five Ministries applied for—and was granted—funds from Oregon’s biennial Youth Community Investment Grants program. When it applied for the next cycle, the ministry was first approved and then denied funding due to a new rule that requires that applicants “do not discriminate” based on religion “in [their] employment practices.” ADF attorneys filed the original lawsuit in March.
“71Five provides vital support and care to anyone who needs it, but Oregon officials are punishing it because it’s a Christian ministry that reasonably asks volunteers and staff to agree to Christian beliefs,” said ADF Senior Counsel Jeremiah Galus. “By stripping 71Five of its funding, Oregon put religious ministries to an unconstitutional choice: hire those who reject your beliefs to receive funding that everyone else can access or go without the funding. We are urging the court to revive the ministry’s case so that it can fully restore its constitutionally protected freedoms.”
In 2021, 71Five had the top-rated application for the Youth Violence and Gang Prevention grant. After applying for several grants during the 2023-2025 grant cycle, the state first accepted the applications, and 71Five was set to receive more than $400,000 in grant funding. But three months later, a state official contacted the ministry’s executive director and informed him the ministry had been disqualified because of the statement of faith that employees and volunteers sign. ADF attorneys note that Oregon officials granted funds to secular organizations that discriminate in services—like one program that posted on its website why it serves girls but does not serve boys—yet 71Five serves everyone and asks only that its employees and volunteers agree with Christian teaching.
“The Department’s double standard also reveals a mechanism of individualized assessments and reflects its religious hostility,” the opening brief states. “The Department celebrated the secular grantees’ conduct as ‘culturally responsive’ yet demeaned 71Five’s commitments as ‘discrimination.’ This the First Amendment does not allow.”
71Five welcomes everyone to participate in its programs, and it serves young people in Oregon of all faiths and backgrounds, including at-risk youth, young people in detention centers and correctional facilities, and expectant and parenting teens. The ministry’s mission statement says it “exists to share God’s Story of Hope with young people through trusting relationships in any relevant way.” It achieves its goal through employees and volunteers who share its mission and beliefs, as outlined by its statement of faith.
Thank you for reading our content. If you would like to receive ZENIT’s daily e-mail news, you can subscribe for free through this link.
