(ZENIT News / Rome, 10.22.2024).- The Vatican and the People’s Republic of China have once again renewed their groundbreaking provisional agreement on the appointment of bishops, marking another step in the evolving relationship between the Holy See and Beijing. The deal, initially signed on September 22, 2018, has now been extended for an additional four years following a mutual decision made on October 22, 2024. This third renewal reflects both parties’ commitment to dialogue and cooperation, with hopes of further fostering the unity of the Catholic Church in China and improving bilateral relations.
This agreement, first hailed as historic, allowed for all bishops in China to be in full communion with the Pope—a significant shift after decades of division, during which many Chinese bishops were appointed without Vatican approval. The latest renewal underscores the continuation of this effort, which has already seen the appointment and consecration of several bishops in the country under mutual consent.
The Road to a Constructive Dialogue
In the official joint statement, both the Vatican and Beijing emphasized their intention to maintain a «respectful and constructive» dialogue. The Vatican sees this renewal as crucial for ensuring the stability and future of the Catholic Church in China. By promoting cooperation, the agreement is seen as a way to enhance not just Church governance, but also the well-being of the broader Chinese population.
«The Holy See and the People’s Republic of China, in light of the consensus achieved for the fruitful implementation of the Provisional Agreement on the appointment of bishops, have agreed after proper consultations to extend its validity for another four years,» the statement read. It further added that the Vatican remains focused on fostering bilateral relations «for the good of the Catholic Church in the country and the entire Chinese people.»
This commitment to constructive engagement highlights the Vatican’s delicate balancing act—pursuing its mission in a country where religious practice is tightly regulated, while maintaining the independence of Church decisions.
A New Era for the Catholic Church in China
Since the agreement was first signed in 2018, it has transformed the Church’s position within China. Before the deal, episcopal appointments were often made without the Vatican’s approval, leading to a fractured leadership. Now, with the renewed framework in place, the Church has seen the appointment of more than ten bishops with the consent of both Rome and Beijing. Additionally, several bishops who had previously been in irregular standing with the Vatican have been officially recognized by both sides.
This new atmosphere of collaboration has also facilitated greater Chinese participation in the global Catholic community. Chinese bishops, previously excluded from official Vatican gatherings, now attend Synods in Rome and other significant Church events across Europe and the Americas. Additionally, young Chinese Catholics were notably present at last year’s World Youth Day in Lisbon, further signaling a growing openness and involvement in the international Church.
Pope Francis’ recent apostolic trips to Asia, where Chinese faithful participated openly, is another testament to this shift. The presence of Chinese Catholics in global religious events indicates that, despite the complexities of the relationship, the Catholic community in China is eager to be a part of the broader Church.
Challenges and Criticism
Despite these advancements, the agreement remains a point of contention both within and outside the Church. Critics, including some within the Vatican, argue that the deal gives the Chinese government too much control over Church matters, particularly in a country where religious freedom remains a sensitive issue. Others have expressed concerns about the treatment of underground Catholic communities that remain loyal to the Vatican but do not have official recognition from the Chinese government.
While the Vatican has stressed that the agreement focuses solely on the issue of episcopal appointments, leaving broader questions of religious freedom unaddressed, it is clear that this renewal is part of a broader strategy. Pope Francis, who has consistently emphasized dialogue and diplomacy, sees this as a long-term process of building trust and securing the future of the Catholic Church in China.
Looking Forward: Continued Cooperation
With the agreement now extended until 2028, the next four years will be critical for the future of Catholicism in China. The Holy See hopes that the ongoing dialogue will not only lead to more bishop appointments under mutual consent but also allow for greater religious freedom and pastoral care for China’s estimated 12 million Catholics.
Thank you for reading our content. If you would like to receive ZENIT’s daily e-mail news, you can subscribe for free through this link.
