Answered by Legionary of Christ Father Edward McNamara, professor of liturgy and sacramental theology and director of the Sacerdos Institute at the Regina Apostolorum university.
Q: As a religious living in community, I have noticed that both priests and those studying to be priests frequently have recourse to exposing the Blessed Sacrament reserved in a kind of mini monstrance in the tabernacle of the private oratory of the community. They do this while entirely alone, without employing any vestments, possibly lighting some candles and place the monstrance with host on an opened corporal upon the altar’s mensa. The present liturgical books are clear that exposition in the monstrance requires a congregation, four or six lighted candles, incense, singing, and vestments. However, with every other kind of liturgical celebration being open to simplification, exposition in the monstrance also seems to be going in the same direction. Is there anything more explicit than what is already in De sacra communione et de cultu mysterii eucharistici extra missam? Perhaps something from before Vatican II which might still apply? I recall reading a note by a commentator from before Vatican II stating explicitly that exposition for the personal devotion of the priest while entirely alone was expressly prohibited, but I don’t recall where I read it. — F.R., Rome
A: As far as I know, there have been no new universal norms regarding exposition, although some norms have been clarified by official responses to doubts. And there are several documents from bishops’ conferences that offer good explanations of the regulations.
In this regard, I think it is important to recall that the ordinary means of adoration in the Catholic Church is before the tabernacle.
We should also recall the distinction between simple and solemn exposition. In current Church discipline, simple adoration is with the closed pyx or ciborium. There are no other forms of simple exposition.
If the host is visible in any way whatsoever, it is solemn exposition and incense should be used for exposition. It makes no difference at all if the monstrance is large or small, placed upon the altar (the preferred option) or in the tabernacle.
Among the clarifications offered by bishops’ conferences, the following is offered by the U.S. bishops’ conference Secretariat for the Liturgy in its September 2006 BCL newsletter:
“Nine Questions on the Rites for Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament
“In recent months, the Secretariat for the Liturgy has received several inquiries concerning the proper rites for adoration of the exposed Blessed Sacrament. While several of these inquiries are answered in the BCL publication ‘Thirty-one Questions on Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament,’ a few additional clarifications are provided here for the information of our readers.
“1. How does adoration of the exposed Blessed Sacrament differ from adoration of the Holy Eucharist reserved in the tabernacle?
“Eucharistic adoration of the reserved Blessed Sacrament is a devotional act. Eucharistic exposition is a liturgical action, by which the Blessed Sacrament is displayed outside the tabernacle in a monstrance or ciborium for public veneration by the faithful. It is a public celebration that enables the faithful to perceive more clearly the relationship between the reserved Sacrament and the ‘sacrifice of the Mass [which] is truly the origin and the purpose of the worship that is shown to the Eucharist outside Mass.’ (Eucharisticum mysterium, no. 3e)
“2. What are the liturgical rites for adoration of the exposed Blessed Sacrament? These rites are found in the third chapter [of the] ritual book Holy Communion and Worship of the Eucharist Outside Mass [HCW], entitled Forms of Worship of the Holy Eucharist. The rites for adoration of the exposed Blessed Sacrament are found in numbers 82-100. These rites consist of Exposition, Adoration, Benediction, and Reposition of the Blessed Sacrament.
“3. What are the rites of Exposition and Adoration? While the Blessed Sacrament is exposed, and the ciborium or monstrance is placed upon the altar, it is fitting that a song be sung by those gathered. If the monstrance is used (rather than the ciborium) the minister incenses the sacrament. (Cf. HCW, no. 93). For the period of adoration, ‘there should be prayers, songs, and readings to direct the attention of the faithful to the worship of Christ the Lord.’ (HCW, no. 95) A homily or brief exhortation is also appropriate, as are extended periods of silence.
“4. What are the Rites of Benediction and Reposition? For the rites of Benediction, described in HCW, no. 97, the Priest incenses the Blessed Sacrament in the monstrance, prays one of the prescribed prayers (cf. HCW, nos. 98, 224-229), and, with the humeral veil, silently makes the sign of the cross over the people. (cf. HCW, no. 99) As the Blessed Sacrament is then reposed in the tabernacle, the people may sing an acclamation. (cf. HCW, no. 100)
“5. When the Blessed Sacrament is exposed, how many candles should be used? ‘For exposition of the Blessed Sacrament in the monstrance, four to six candles are lighted and incense is used. For exposition of the Blessed Sacrament in the ciborium, at least two candles should be lighted, and incense may be used.’ (HCW, no. 85)
“6. What vesture should be worn for the rites of Adoration of the exposed Blessed Sacrament? ‘The minister, if he is a priest or deacon, should vest in an alb, or a surplice over a cassock, and a stole. Other ministers should wear either the liturgical vestments which are used in the region or the vesture which is suitable for this ministry and which has been approved by the Ordinary. The priest or deacon should wear a white cope and humeral veil to give the blessing at the end of adoration when the exposition takes place with the monstrance; in the case of exposition in the ciborium, the humeral veil should be worn.’ (HCW, no. 92)
“7. May these rites be adapted or shortened for particular circumstances? No. The liturgical rites may not be adapted or shortened beyond the scope envisioned by the rubrics of Holy Communion and Worship of the Eucharist Outside Mass. Simply opening the tabernacle to enhance private or devotional prayer, is not in conformity with the liturgical requirements of HCW, nos. 93-85. It might be noted, however, that the Benediction is omitted when the exposition is led by a layperson. (cf. HCW, no. 91)
“8. Is it permissible to use an ‘Exposition Tabernacle,’ which includes a small window with a sliding cover, for exposition of the Blessed Sacrament? No. ‘The Holy Eucharist is to be reserved in a solid tabernacle. It must be opaque and unbreakable.’ (HCW, no. 10; Cf. Code of Canon Law, 938 §3; General Instruction of the Roman Missal, no. 314.
“9. May Evening Prayer (Vespers) be celebrated in the presence of the exposed Blessed Sacrament? Yes. ‘Part of the liturgy of the hours, especially the principal hours, may be celebrated before the Blessed Sacrament when there is a lengthy period of exposition. This liturgy extends the praise and thanksgiving offered to God in the Eucharistic celebration to the several hours of the day; it directs the prayers of the Church to Christ and through him to the Father in the name of the whole world.’ (HCW, no. 96)”
As can be seen, all of these clarifications are based on universal law and are not specific to the United States.
It is thus clear that exposition is always a public and community activity honoring Christ in the Blessed Sacrament and never merely an aid to personal devotion. This public and community activity may be done in brief general periods of exposition or by taking turns in a more prolonged exposition (Rite of Holy Communion and Eucharistic Worship Outside of Mass: 82; 89-90).
Exposition should not be seen as a psychological aid to mental prayer. That is not its function in the Church. The Church grants the same indulgences for adoration before the tabernacle as before the exposed host.
As a consequence, neither a priest nor any other minister may expose the Blessed Sacrament only for personal devotion. The faculties granted to any minister are for the benefit of the faithful even when the minister also obtains spiritual fruits from this service.
Before the conciliar reform priests could open the tabernacle for simple adoration with the closed ciborium as a means of personal devotion. Although this possibility has not been formally abrogated, it is quite rare in current practice.
* * *
Readers may send questions to email@example.com. Please put the word “Liturgy” in the subject field. The text should include your initials, your city, and your state, province or country. Father McNamara can only answer a small selection of the great number of questions that arrive.